A couple of days ago, I wrote about how China issued a travel warning for Japan, advising citizens against traveling to the country. The government of China argued that Japan was “unstable, with a high number of criminal incidents targeting Chinese citizens,” and the “security environment” has “continued to deteriorate.”
In reality, it seemed pretty clear that this was simply part of a diplomatic spat, with Japan’s new Prime Minister showing support for Taiwan, in the event that China tries to invade. I was curious to what extent these travel warnings would actually impact demand, and now we have our answer…
In this post:
32% of tickets to Japan canceled amid diplomatic issues
Following China’s recent travel warning, several Chinese airlines issued flight waivers for Japan, allowing customers to rebook their tickets at no cost.
So, just how many people are actually canceling their flights? According to the South China Morning Post, Chinese airlines have seen roughly 491,000 flight cancelations to Japan since Saturday, representing around 32% of tickets that have been booked for travel over that waiver period. This is the highest number of cancelations that have been seen in the market since the start of the coronavirus pandemic.
As another interesting figure, on Sunday, 27 times more people canceled flights between China and Japan than booked tickets.
China is among the largest markets for visiting Japan, with over seven million visitors from mainland China having visited Japan in the first nine months of the year. And it’s also a very fast growing market, since that number is over 40% higher than the number of visitors during that same period the year prior.
It’s going to be interesting to see how long this spat lasts
When I wrote about China’s travel warning against Japan, some people took issue with what I wrote. While I’ll gladly admit when I’m wrong, as of now, I stand by what I said.
Japan is one of the safest places in the world you can travel to, so to suggest that travelers from China face a high number of criminal incidents in Japan compared to just about anywhere else in the world is, to my knowledge, baseless.
For example, some people pointed out how in June, a Chinese national was stabbed in the chest multiple times on the streets of Kyoto (fortunately with non-life threatening injuries). The issue with that narrative is that the person who has been charged with that crime is a Chinese national who had overstayed his visa, and the two had reportedly gotten into an argument.
I’ll gladly update my stance if someone can show me these alleged widespread crimes that I’m missing, but it seems pretty clear to me what the motive here is.
Obviously China isn’t happy about Japan’s lack of support for the “reunification” of Taiwan, and this is about diplomatic concerns rather than actual safety concerns. Could there be some bad blood between Chinese and Japanese nationals? Sure. But does it seem likely that Chinese nationals will be attacked unprovoked by Japanese nationals? I think that’s highly unlikely…
I’m curious to see how this all plays out. Japan is of course one of the hottest tourist destinations in the world, and has been suffering from over tourism. So honestly, if this means there will be a little less demand for travel to Japan, maybe that’s not so bad for the rest of us.
Bottom line
China issued a travel warning for Japan, claiming there are a high number of criminal incidents targeting Chinese nationals. In reality, it seems pretty clear that this warning is politically motivated, given Japan’s government showing support for Taiwan.
I wasn’t sure to what extent this would impact travel demand, but travelers do seem to be taking note. Chinese airlines have reportedly seen 32% of tickets canceled, with very few new tickets still being booked. While tourism makes up a big part of Japan’s economy nowadays, fortunately the visitor profile is quite diversified, with demand from all over the world.
How long do you think we’re going to see this depressed travel demand between China and Japan?
Fewer rude and inconsiderate mainlanders in Japan? awesome.
PRC Chinese tourists are very obnixious. They're loud, spit eveywhere and have no decorum
CCP bots out in full force in the comment section
For the proletariat online spaces can act as surrogate communities and outrage may have become the proletariat’s way to feel engaged and relevant. So has the proletariat well and truly lost the plot? That is the $64,000 question.
The proletariat raised on a clear moral frameworks …. right/wrong, respect/disrespect …. is now navigating an information world defined by fluidity and ambiguity. This clash fuels what is called intolerance of uncertainty, where, as seen during the pandemic, conspiracy theories flourish and anger becomes a coping strategy.
Loser.
A lot of yapping but zero contribution. Great job as usual
lol what drugs are you on?
the issue will fix itself after Japan comes to its senses and apologies
That's what Xi said... (but, he's still wrong to think that.)
Tourists. Soybeans. Rare earths. Canola. Another reminder to other countries of China's enormous clout.
That's what Xi said... (and it's a great reminder to the world to not trust the CCP.)
Blogs like this just shows how little they understand international politics. Obviously this is a diplomatic nightmare for Japan.
Masaaki Kanai, head of the Asian and Oceanian Affairs Bureau at Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs Rushed to Beijing immediately but left empty handed.
Look, while western tourists might see this as a win due to less tourists overall, I can guarantee you it’s catastrophic for Japan economy. You just don’t understand how this impacts not...
Blogs like this just shows how little they understand international politics. Obviously this is a diplomatic nightmare for Japan.
Masaaki Kanai, head of the Asian and Oceanian Affairs Bureau at Japan's Ministry of Foreign Affairs Rushed to Beijing immediately but left empty handed.
Look, while western tourists might see this as a win due to less tourists overall, I can guarantee you it’s catastrophic for Japan economy. You just don’t understand how this impacts not just tourism but secondary boycotting effects to other japans export industries. Who is japans largest trading partner????? Anyone?
HAH. He left without giving the Chinese anything since the Commies are clearly showing themselves to be unreasonable. Stand strong Japan! The free world stands with Taiwan and Japan.
This.
I am pretty sure that Abe and Ishiba would do what Takaichi said, should China “unifies” Taiwan “by force”. The difference? Not a single sane PM in the past said that in public. Fortunately, most Japanese PMs were sane.
Japan is a resource dependent country. The exact reason they chose to attack Pearl Harbor was the United States embargoed them. Now, Japan is facing both Donnie’s tariffs and China’s diplomatic tensions that would very...
This.
I am pretty sure that Abe and Ishiba would do what Takaichi said, should China “unifies” Taiwan “by force”. The difference? Not a single sane PM in the past said that in public. Fortunately, most Japanese PMs were sane.
Japan is a resource dependent country. The exact reason they chose to attack Pearl Harbor was the United States embargoed them. Now, Japan is facing both Donnie’s tariffs and China’s diplomatic tensions that would very likely end up in trade limitations. Guess how their economy will be affected?
No politicians’ call should stop general public from broadening their horizons by traveling abroad. However, even from a completely realpolitik perspective, I still do not believe Takaichi’s remarks about Taiwan is wise.
When did OMAAT get infiltrated by Chinese online bots and trolls?
I donno, Eve; doesn't mean we have to 'let them' spread their CCP propaganda unanswered.
Some will suggest, ignore the trolls. Naw, I'd rather 'troll the trolls.'
I'd rather say 'no,' and counter their lies.
The wu mao got the call this week and are hard at work. Those of us westerners who have lived in China know Ben is spot on
I calling Ben out not for his stance on Japan being safe for tourists… I think majority of folks know this is propaganda from China. But that’s totally expected.
I’m calling Ben out for thinking this is a silly save face tactic from China… I am here to tell you that Japan is taking the actions by China very seriously because they understand the implications.
They (Japan) need to save face too and can’t just...
I calling Ben out not for his stance on Japan being safe for tourists… I think majority of folks know this is propaganda from China. But that’s totally expected.
I’m calling Ben out for thinking this is a silly save face tactic from China… I am here to tell you that Japan is taking the actions by China very seriously because they understand the implications.
They (Japan) need to save face too and can’t just take back PMs comments. But they are desperately trying to find a way out of this as evident by japans eagerness to start talking to China.
@Davisson
That is Oriental Wisdom! Just like Japan still call **losing WW2 as an Axis nation** as "shuusen" (lit. end of the war) or China calls Cultural Revolution "bumpy trip towards socialism", they will not recall the remarks because if they do, domestic "netouyo" (lit. right wing on the internet), Takaichi's loyalist force, will call Takaichi traitor and drop support to her. Japan has a long tradition of doing so in the last century,...
@Davisson
That is Oriental Wisdom! Just like Japan still call **losing WW2 as an Axis nation** as "shuusen" (lit. end of the war) or China calls Cultural Revolution "bumpy trip towards socialism", they will not recall the remarks because if they do, domestic "netouyo" (lit. right wing on the internet), Takaichi's loyalist force, will call Takaichi traitor and drop support to her. Japan has a long tradition of doing so in the last century, and it directly led to the election of Tojo cabinet, and we all know what happened next
Now, the right wing mobs would rather have the entire nation suffer an economic hit just to save face and tell the story that they can be harsh on China. Sounds Juche to me.
lol great old school wolf warrior agitprop there Davisson
just as with the US-Canada spat, Chinese airlines are taking the biggest hit in declines.
Airplanes are mobile factories and can be moved but there will be a financial hit to the state-owned Chinese airlines.
Sounds like Canada when the American leadership offended them, except Trump was much ruder to them than the Japanese have been to China.
"Japan is one of the safest places in the world you can travel to".
If you are a white man (gay or straight), Ben.
I don't think woman share this.
That surprises me. Can you provide evidence?
I'm not saying Chinese travelers are facing widespread danger more than non-Chinese travelers, but at least in Korea (can't speak to Japan, where I haven't been recently) there is a much, much higher degree of anxiety and what would be called racism in the US against China and Chinese people out in the open compared to even a few years ago.
The last president openly supported a conspiracy theory that multiple elections were rigged.
Which included blaming China for everything.
Somehow this triggered the majority of Korean old dudes and males in their 20s-30s.
Then they started to march in streets and that's what you saw.
Honestly, given their economic dependence, how dumb that they do that and think they're acting patriot.
Good for tourist from other countries to visit during this period but I doubt it will be good for Japanese economy.
It's been tanking for a while with prices going up every year for locals.
Japan had too much tourists coming in, and seeing a reduction in their quantity seems to be a good thing.
Looking forward for this December.
Maybe a bit hurtful for the new Abenomics Takaichi wants to push which includes promoting foreigners' spending within Japan. But it's not like Japan is gonna die because of that.
If only the same thing could happen with bookings from the US what a lovely time it would be to visit Japan
Should probably look into airfares between the two countries. Maybe I can finally afford to fly in First.
Prices are still stable.
We thinkin' recliner 'First' (a321 or 737, meh, lame, or with Air China, a Comac C919, yikes, avoid), or like JAL/ANA (777) legit 'First'?
ANA and JAL do operate 777s between China and Japan while you may sit in The Suite with business class service. JAL’s F seats sold as J are for OW EMDs only and ANA’s are for its own Diamond only.
Everyone I know in Japan in relieved to have fewer tourists. This might hurt if the country weren't about as hot as you can get without Mike White doing a show there.
This might be a good thing to increase tourism actually. As all the other tourist will be happy all the Chinese tourists are gone.
And everyone loved that!
Chinese tend to travel abroad as part of tour groups. I bet a few old people panicked and the tour groups cancelled all bookings to reduce financial risk.
A lot of major Chinese travel companies are owned by some state investment vehicle so it won’t be surprising to see heavy state interference on the travel plans
Oh no! ...anyway.
That's what Xi said.