Delta Air Lines has clarified its onboard photography policy, as reported by PYOK, and I’m impressed by the way the airline has gone about this. Separately, the airline has also updated its employee social media policy.
In this post:
The challenge with airline photography rules
With a vast majority of travelers having smartphones, we can all take pictures and videos at a moment’s notice. Many people enjoy taking pictures when they fly, and not just because they’re like me, and are thoroughly reviewing flights.
Admittedly this creates a challenging situation for airlines. While a vast majority of airlines let you take take pictures as long as other people aren’t in them, there’s a grey area. What happens if an employee appears in the picture, even if you’re not meaning to take a picture specifically of them? What happens if something negative occurs on your flight, and you want to capture proof?
There’s no right or wrong answer here, but we’ve seen a number of viral incidents over the years. In the case of Delta, earlier this year we saw some social media posts go viral of Delta flight attendants wearing flags in support of Palestine.
This was a lose-lose situation. Not only were many people online angry at Delta for allowing this, but Delta employees also largely felt frustrated that their faces were being plastered over the internet, and the company wasn’t defending them. This caused the Atlanta-based carrier to update its policy on wearing flag pins. That also brings us to the latest update.
Delta rolls out logical new photography policy
Delta has issued a memo to employees, entitled “Our approach to customer photos/videos,” reportedly in response to a number of Delta employees requesting that Delta prohibit photography taken without employee consent.
Delta has taken time to review its policy, and came to an interesting conclusion — Delta employees can’t tell customers to stop photographing or videoing them, and can’t kick passengers off flights for that reason. As the memo explains:
“We know most customers are well-intended and document their travel experience as a normal and fun part of the journey, and employees do the same when they travel.”
“Delta is a common carrier by air, meaning we are obligated to transport any passenger who pays our fare and agrees to our contract of carriage. Common carriers (aircraft, trains, subways, buses, etc.) cannot restrict customer conduct to the same degree that other businesses can, and we cannot implement or institute rules that are inconsistent with laws and regulations.”
“You’ve likely seen gyms or other businesses implement a no-photo policy. Those private businesses are permitted to implement such policies because they do not operate under the same regulations as airlines.”
Delta has concluded that while passengers do have to follow crew member instructions, this has to be based on Federal Aviation Regulations (FARs), and they don’t address restrictions on photography.
Delta does have one carve-out when it comes to being able to photograph employees. Specifically, it’s not allowed “when the content captured is not well intentioned,” like if it “interferes with the safety and security of flight or if the behavior interferes with the safety or security of employees and customers.” But even in those situations, employees are told to focus on de-escalation, and leverage the support they have from ground teams and pilots.
Now, Delta employees are still allowed to ask passengers to respect their privacy and avoid including them in photos, but they “cannot force them to stop, nor may we remove someone from a flight merely because they took a photo or video.” So such a request would be a courtesy, rather than an official order.
While this has been published internally, Delta has also updated its “onboard experience” page, to add the following note for customers:
We recognize that capturing content is a standard part of customers’ travel experiences. However, capturing content should not interfere with the safety or security of flight, fellow customers or our employees. We ask that you are mindful of including Delta employees in that content, and respectful in your intent.
Bottom line
Delta has updated its onboard photography policy, and it’s probably the most detailed and well thought out policy we’ve seen from an airline. Passengers are allowed to take pictures, including of others, as long as it’s well intentioned.
Admittedly that remains open to interpretation, but this seems more logical than a policy that strictly prohibits photos with others in them, which seems highly unrealistic (even when you take a selfie, others may appear in the background). The airline is factoring intention into whether photography is allowed, and that’s always tough to define. But still, this seems better than before.
What do you make of Delta’s updated photography policy?
Finally, some sanity.
This new directive is clear. Very good!
"We ask that you are mindful of including Delta employees in that content, and respectful in your intent."
Lol.
This is why I prefer your blog to all the others. The effort you put in to getting clean photos and not disturbing others is much appreciated in a world where that is sadly far from the norm
It's not just thoughtful. It is based on law.
Common carriers don't have the freedom to impose a bunch of rules that coddle any group, employees included.
Outside the US, and especially in Europe, there are strict rules enforcing photography of staff and other customers. In some countries it’s prohibited. Americans especially seem to believe they can film staff and post on
Social media without permission if they dispute something. I’ve seen so many videos with them trying to defend their rights, even referring to the US constitution, which they probably never read.
Some airlines make pre flight announcements reminding...
Outside the US, and especially in Europe, there are strict rules enforcing photography of staff and other customers. In some countries it’s prohibited. Americans especially seem to believe they can film staff and post on
Social media without permission if they dispute something. I’ve seen so many videos with them trying to defend their rights, even referring to the US constitution, which they probably never read.
Some airlines make pre flight announcements reminding customers.
Delta operates beyond US borders, therefore customers have to also comply with regulations outside the US
According to Ben's article, Delta did not distinguish between operations in the US and elsewhere.
DL is a US based company and operates no flights solely within the borders of any other country.
and, from a legal perspective, I'm not sure that a foreign government's policy applies onboard DL aircraft on a flight from any destination to/from the US.
My understanding is that the laws of the carrier's 'home' jurisdiction apply when the aircraft doors are closed and local laws apply when the doors are open- which obviously includes the embarkation and disembarkation process at all international outstations.
and that is probably true.
If there really is an issue on the ground in country X, I am sure that local ground staff will make an announcement to that effect.
In reality, it isn't a big deal for the vast majority of people or employees.
and, btw, I have flown over countries where instructions were given to not open the window shades or take pictures out of the aircraft - so those announcements can and are made.
No they dont. We get it you are anti American. But yet, you read an American's blog that is heavily focused to the American audience.
That argument doesn't seem too plausible because during Covid, Delta and other US airlines had mask mandates long before the feds mandated it.
While the photo rule makes sense, a stricter rule is legally possible.
Violating a rule wouldn't be a crime but as stated in the conditions of carriage, violators can be banned.
Photography should always be allowed if the script justifies it.
If Tim Dunn comes here and writes a college essay-long comment praising Delta, I'm all for it this time.
Very good move Delta.
Maybe you and Tim can get a room.