Ouch: Ryanair Passe...
 

Ouch: Ryanair Passengers Fly 8+ Hours, Only To End Up Where They Started

24 Posts
11 Users
0 Reactions
739 Views
Posts: 41023
Admin
Topic starter
(@lucky)
Member
Joined: 13 years ago
[#20448]
wpf-cross-image

A Ryanair flight from Alicante to Newquay diverted to Dublin, then headed for Bristol, and finally returned to Alicante, leaving passengers eight hours onboard and right back where they began.


23 Replies
Posts: 1479
(@George Romey)
Joined: 6 years ago

Are there restrictions on which crews can operate a flight? Ryanair has those cheap fares people constantly claim to be so wonderful because it sources labor cheaply.


Reply
2 Replies
Admin
(@lucky)
Joined: 13 years ago

Member
Posts: 41023

@ George Romey -- Yeah, crews can only operate on the air operator certificate of the subsidiary they work for, as I understand it.


Reply
(@Sam Goss)
Joined: 3 weeks ago

Posts: 1

Crew can switch freely between Ireland and Malta reg aircraft.

Ryanair UK & Lauda are separate, though depending on the circumstances other subsidiaries aircraft & crew can operate the flights (which Ryanair UK often pushes the limits of / falls out with the UK CAA over!)

Considering the weather and the amount of disruption across UK & Ireland I suspect there wasn't readily available crew at Dublin . Plus diverting beyond Bristol / Exeter etc the road transfer to Newquay would become impossible to arrange, it's a very long drive to Cornwall, trains not at an option at that time and hotels near airports would be busy with all the disruption earlier in the day.

I actually do not think Ryanair made a bad call here, avoided further disruption the next day for more passengers needing that aircraft, likely plenty of hotel availability near Alicante this time of year. Hopefully people got rebooked swiftly.


Reply
Posts: 34
 Mike
(@Mike)
Joined: 14 years ago

Pay for what you get, unfortunately.


Reply
1 Reply
(@Icarus)
Joined: 11 years ago

Posts: 2604

It’s absolutely nothing to do with the ticket price. Idiotic comment There was a severe storm over much of Ireland and the UK.


Reply
Posts: 260
Diamond
(@klaus_s)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

Actually EC261 compensation does apply. In the end, Ryanair decided to fly back to Alicante due to operational reasons.
Ryanair had multiple opportunities to bring their passengers to Alicante:

Translation from German:
“To invoke force majeure, the airline must demonstrate that the event was entirely beyond its normal sphere of operations and that it took all reasonable measures (e.g. deploying replacement aircraft, rebooking passengers onto trains or other airlines) to avoid the damage.”


Reply
3 Replies
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1840

Of course, I'm a huge fan of EU261. If Ryanair wants to argue the defense of 'extraordinary circumstances' here to avoid statutory compensation, that's their burden (to prove it was the weather). However, there is no exception for duty of care; Ryanair must reimburse out-of-pocket hotels, meals, prompt rebooking for all the affected passengers, if applicable.


Reply
 Ross
(@Ross)
Joined: 12 years ago

Posts: 582

One online source suggests that passengers have a choice between EU261 and UK261 -- and 220 pounds is slightly more than 250 euros. So, would it come down to which court system is more friendly?


Reply
Diamond
(@klaus_s)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 260

@Ross: I would choose UK because the CEDR is quite good and also because they speak English - if i would need to go to court.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 260
Diamond
(@klaus_s)
Member
Joined: 3 years ago

EC261 compensation is pretty much always payable. The bar for claiming extraordinary circumstances is very high: the airline must have taken all reasonable measures to get passengers to their destination as quickly as possible, despite the weather.

Put more vividly: unless you end up stranded on Midway Atoll in the middle of the night due to engine failure while all global air traffic is suspended because of a UFO sighting, you’re probably entitled to EU261 compensation. (Well, as Long as you are flying with an European airline/departed from Europe/ will have a connecting flight from a European airport.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1840

(Oh, cool, hyperbole...) It's a bit more nuanced then you suggest, but, sure, EU261 is usually a great consumer protection. However, it doesn't cover everything. For instance, if an itinerary starts and ends outside the EU—even if booked through an EU carrier and with a connection in the EU—ironically, EU261 protection doesn't apply (AirHelp v. Austrian Airlines, C-451/20). Wish they'd've closed a few of those loopholes during the latest re-affirmation of the regulation...


Reply
Posts: 1496
(@santastico)
Member
Joined: 6 years ago

While I see the financial advantage of sometimes flying budget airlines vs regular carriers, the main thing that comes to mind is optionality. Being based at MSP, many times I am tempted to fly Sun Country vs Delta but then I realize Delta has many flights per day to a destination when Sun Country only has one very two days. Thus, in the event of something going wrong with Sun Country, I am in a much worse situation than if the same happens to Delta. In Europe is a bit different since budget airlines usually fly to unique destinations that most regular carriers don't but again that is a risky situation if something goes bad.


Reply
1 Reply
Diamond
(@klaus_s)
Joined: 3 years ago

Member
Posts: 260

Also in europe it’s a bit different because budget airlines have to rebook you to the next available flight. And if they don’t, you can book a flight for yourself (and get the cost reimbursed).
At least for now.
In 2027, there will be a Price Cap of the original ticket Price of 400%. Good Lobbying, Ryanair.

Passengers who choose to re-route at the earliest opportunity must be offered an alternative route within three hours. This may include re-routing to an alternative airport, a different route, the services of another airline or other means of transport. The re-routing must be provided at the airline’s expense and under comparable conditions of carriage. Passengers, for example, should not be forced to take multiple connecting flights if they have booked a direct flight. Travellers may also be upgraded to a higher class of service at no extra cost.
“If an airline does not offer an alternative flight within three hours, passengers may arrange their own alternative flight and claim a refund of up to 400 per cent of the original ticket price,” states the EU Council.


Reply
Posts: 73
 Jack
(@Jack)
Joined: 9 years ago

Ryanair flyers don't love themselves enough.


Reply
Posts: 175
Diamond
(@mildmidwesterner)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

If you're on Ryanair, don't you already know that your life isn't going anywhere?


Reply
2 Replies
Diamond
(@1990_)
Joined: 3 months ago

Member
Posts: 1840

Oh, how fun it is to mock them. Yet, love them or hate them, LCCs perform an important economic function... disciplining legacy airline pricing (a lesson we’re learning the hard way in the US after Spirit). Ryanair and EasyJet hold over 40% of the intra-EU market. Without airlines like FR undercutting fares, legacy carriers like BA and LH would face little pressure to keep short-haul prices reasonable. So, you don't have to enjoy the seat pitch, lack of recline, or a flight to nowhere to appreciate that LCCs keep the oligopoly in-check.


Reply
 Nick
(@Nick)
Joined: 8 years ago

Posts: 18

It's Newquay airport. Unless you're flying to the Scilly Isles it's pretty much the only game in town unless you want to drive the ~2.5 hours up to Bristol.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 212
Diamond
(@grayanderson)
Member
Joined: 5 years ago

What's particularly galling is that I wouldn't be shocked if some number of passengers would have disembarked in Dublin if they had been told they were going back to Spain.


Reply
Posts: 496
 Samo
Diamond
(@samo)
Member
Joined: 1 year ago

I understand flying the plane back but passengers should've been disembarked in Dublin and rebooked from there. Even Ryanair has a spare aircraft at DUB, which could've been used for this the next day.

Someone needs to crack down on this diverting of flights where it's operationally convenient, irrespective of what it does to passengers. It's becoming a very ugly trend among European airlines.


Reply
Posts: 57
(@timuk)
Member
Joined: 1 year ago

It's hard to judge fully without all the facts.
As it happens, on the following day they had flights from both ALC and DUB to NQY.
Maybe this flight wasn't full and neither was the one the following day, so returning to ALC could have actually been the least troublesome/equal worst option all round.


Reply
Posts: 1969
(@iamhere)
Joined: 10 years ago

I would only take a budget airline if it was the only option between the two points non-stop


Reply
1 Reply
(@jim26)
Joined: 1 year ago

Member
Posts: 4

Newquay is a very small airport (around 500,000 passengers per year). No other non-stop option to Alicante.


Reply

Rewards cardsFind your next travel companionCompare top rewards credit card offersCompare cards

Posts: 401
Diamond
(@omarsidd)
Member
Joined: 2 years ago

That's astonishingly inefficient... Apart from the misery and everybody losing whatever they had planned to do that day, I don't know how this would possibly make sense from a corporate sense.


Reply