Review: The Royal Hawaiian Waikiki
We had only one night in Waikiki on the return portion of our trip, so we considered a few different options. I've reviewed the Hyatt Regency before, which I quite like. This time around I wanted to try one of the SPG options. Starwood has three hotels more or less next to one another on…
Continue reading: Review: The Royal Hawaiian Waikiki
Share your questions, experiences, and thoughts below.
I like this hotel too but the exec lounge is packed tight constantly and you often can't even get a seat.
I'm amazed you're this kind to the rooms here.
I've stayed in the main building and the tower. Old, stained carpets that all sort of smell. Furniture that is scuffed and cracked. Ancient bathrooms. I was once upgraded to a suite in the main building where the second room didn't have a window or air conditioning. Not very pleasant given the weather.
Yes, it's a classic and yes, it's lovely outside, but amazing that you can be so harsh to the Andaz and then dismiss these rooms are charmingly shabby chic. I've started staying next door at the Sheraton. Nicer rooms, same great beach.
It's a Luxury Collection hotel, which (with a few exceptions) means an over-the-hill historic property that the owner is unwilling to renovate to the standard of a modern, five-star luxury hotel. The Royal Hawaiian has a few grand public spaces, but much of the hotel has all the charm of a suburban hospital. Actually, it's bigger than a hospital, as it has 528 rooms. The rooms are generic and unstylish. The food is mediocre and the mai tais terrible. The hideous high-rise Sheraton Waikiki casts a shadow over much of the Royal Hawaiian in the afternoon.
If only you had decided to stay at and review the Trump Waikiki....
I love the Royal Hawaiian; it's my favorite hotel. I've stayed in some wonderful suites over the years (on a complimentary upgrade during short stays), in classic rooms in the historic building, and I've been upgraded twice to the Mailani Tower. It is true that the rooms could be refreshed. I love the liberal use of pink throughout the property -- it is memorable and makes me smile every day I'm there! But it is the staff that make the place special. Everyone from check-in to the turn-down maids is gracious and warm. The ladies who greet and seat you in the Surf Lanai at breakfast are especially welcoming. Every morning, my spouse and I take long walks on Waikiki Beach just like you and Ford did. I'm booked for next April and can't wait.
Yet another assisted living fascility. This time for Japanese people it appears.
I will agree slightly that our author seems a bit more kind to the Royal Hawaiian and its obviously dated decor and furnishings compared with the more harsh review of the Andaz Maui and its modern but bleak decor and furnishings. Perhaps the price point is a factor, as the Andaz is a much more expensive property. But fair is fair. The Royal Hawaiian is a huge property in desperate need for a total refurbishment and room refresh.
To me, a hotel this large is hardly luxury...but it would help if it had nicer room designs and furnishings and much nicer and refreshed/refurbished public spaces. They may be Hawaiian. But they remind me of Hawaii from the 1990s. It’s time to update.
The Platinum Lounge will always be too crowded in a huge hotel like this. But at least it looked more modern and refreshed. The rest of the public spaces and rooms need to have similar ambience.
Perhaps after or while the Sheraton Princess Kaiulani starts its delayed tear down/rebuild/renovation in 2019, the Royal Hawaiian can start its own desperately needed renovation. Rumor has it that a new tower at the Sheraton may be turned into a W or St Regis, which will put pressure on the Royal Hawaiian to update to keep up. Honolulu could use it.
@Jack - maybe you are thinking of Tributes, but of the ~20 LCs I've been to, only a few would fit your description of "an over-the-hill historic property that the owner is unwilling to renovate to the standard of a modern, five-star luxury hotel".
Maybe it would help if you named the others that make up the bulk of the LC brand.
@Neil couldn't agree more. I stayed here in August 2016 and the property was just an utter mess. Overcrowded public areas, poor service from hotel rooms, and badly dated and tattered rooms. Some seem to write this off because of the "historic" nature of the hotel but I found it gross. Although, in fairness, there just aren't many great properties in Waikiki.
Mid-century classic look? I call it bad, dated look. And bad taste. Mid-century is classy, stylish, beautiful. Google for mid-century and look at photos, Ben. 🙂
I think this, with other reviews, proves that your tastes are a bit too "classic" if not dated in my opinion. 😉
For anyone who's looking for something more contemporary in Waikiki, checkout the Halekulani and The Modern.
The Royal Hawaiian does indeed have a tiny pool but as a guest you do have access the shared pool between the Royal and Sheraton Waikiki which is much newer,larger and more in keeping with that of a resort property. Living here in Waikiki, I think of the Starwood properties the Moana Surfrider is the best as long as you take a deluxe ocean view or Suite in the Surfrider tower. Otherwise nothing compares to the Halekulani.
From friends staying at the nearby Trump, got used to the Mai Tai bar at the Royal.
Never stayed in the hotel, but almost always walk by for an evening drink(s) and appetizer.
My favorite hotel in Waikiki is the Kahala Hotel. I've stayed there before when it was the Mandarin Oriental and afterwards - the rooms and lanais are huge, and the most plush carpet. And the beach is as private as you can get for a public beach in Honolulu.
I guess many have forgotten, or don't realize, that the hotel is over 90 years old. So bathrooms are small and views aren't optimized etc., but the property has a warmth and serenity that is SO hard to find in Waikiki. And the staff make it even better. As for the Mai Tai bar, best location and drinks you'll get in Waikiki, period.
I refuse to stay in any of the Waikiki hotels...far too crowded, overpriced and usually the rooms are outdated.
My goto hotel in Honolulu is The Modern, very contemporary and has a great ambience. The hotel never has the feel of being overcrowded. We enjoy the two pool areas especially the "adults only" one (no children!) and the bar area by the pool is very relaxing.
Oh thanks for that one. We'll be in Hawaii next Januar, can't wait. Will make sure to check out the Waikiki.
My wife and I spent part of our honeymoon at the Royal Hawaiian in 1973. While having breakfast one morning, we spoke to a couple celebrating their 50th and had spent their honeymoon there. I always thought it would be neat to do the same. By the way, I wouldn't stay at a trump property if the rooms were free.
Stayed here a couple of years ago via Amex FHR. Got an upgrade to the Tower - definitely better decor there! Not impressed though that the exclusion of alcoholic drinks from the $100 F&B credit (was same on our stay). Given the main reason we'd opted to stay there was previously enjoying the Mai Tai bar, was annoyed to have them then excluded. Was only a one night stay with early departure therefore no other time to use it. Eventually managed to get credit applied after pointing out they should have made this exclusion clear at time of booking.
@Gigi: I know it’s old. I don’t need a massive bathroom. I could however use carpet that doesn’t smell of mildew and bathtubs that are chipped and furniture that doesn’t look like it was purchased at a garage sale.
Stayed at the RH right after it's last refurb and loved it so much I went back after 3 years, and actually stayed in the same suite Ben had on this trip. The room was so run down, with newspaper at your door changed to pick up at the front desk among other things...Amazing how Luxury Collection means so little. I agree with the statement above that LC can mean a grand old building and nothing else germaine to a hotel stay.
Overall, this is a great hotel to visit, though perhaps not to stay. The decor is a throwback to the days when prop aircraft brought Sinatra and Elvis to the pristine beaches. You almost feel transported back to a day before Pearl Harbor. It's old, but very purposefully so, and well maintained. Like the Hotel del Coronado in San Diego. It stands in stark comparison to the gentrification of Waikiki as a whole. The Mai Tai Bar is a wonderful place to relax and people watch over a drink and appetizer. The location is just first rate, too. You have Waikiki at your fingertips.
Just had a six day stay in Waikiki prior to catching a cruise liner back to Australia,normally have always stayed at the Royal Hawaiian or Moana Surfrider, this time no suitable rooms available so moved over to the Kahala Resort, which was excellent, both room and atmosphere. Ben,s comments about Waikiki are very true the main street Kalakalua Avenue is very run down and most of the hotels both from the outside perspective and inside are in urgent need of repair or refurbishment. This does not seem to stop the operators of these hotels charging exorbitant rates for rooms compared with 5 star quality properties on the mainland USA i.e. Florida, California. A suggestion if you are going to Hawaii unless it is critical go to Maui !! and miss Waikiki altogether.
